Rogue makes a persuasive gas-SUV case with 201 horsepower and up to 74.1 cubic feet of cargo, while RAV4 and CR-V emphasize different efficiency, space, and powertrain priorities.
Direct answer
The best fit depends on drivetrain and space priorities. The 2026.5 Rogue is a gas-only choice with 201 horsepower and up to 74.1 cubic feet of maximum cargo; the 2026 RAV4 lineup emphasizes hybrid efficiency; and the 2026 CR-V offers gas and hybrid choices, with the gas version publishing the largest maximum cargo figure here. Compare equivalent trims, drivetrains, equipment and out-the-door prices.
Which one should you choose?
Choose Nissan Rogue
- Choose it for 201 horsepower, up to 74.1 cubic feet of cargo space—more maximum cargo than the listed RAV4—and a gas-only compact-SUV routine.
- Its 100.4-to-105.4-cubic-foot passenger-volume range depends on moonroof configuration.
- Confirm the exact 2026.5 trim because cargo and EPA estimates vary.
Choose Toyota RAV4
- Choose it when a hybrid-only core lineup and up to 47 city/40 highway mpg fit your priorities.
- Its available FWD and AWD hybrid systems make 226 or 236 combined horsepower.
- Choose another vehicle if its 70.4-cubic-foot maximum cargo area is less useful for your load.
Choose Honda CR-V
- Choose gas for 190 horsepower or hybrid for 204 total-system horsepower.
- Its gas configuration provides up to 39.3 cubic feet behind row two and 76.5 maximum.
- Compare gas and hybrid cargo and passenger volumes because the battery changes the published figures.
How do the specifications compare?
On a small screen, scroll horizontally to compare every column.
| Decision | 2026.5 Nissan Rogue | 2026 Toyota RAV4 | 2026 Honda CR-V |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seating capacity | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| Output | 201 hp | 226 hp FWD / 236 hp AWD hybrid | 190 hp gas / 204 hp hybrid system |
| Cargo behind second row | 36.3–36.5 cu. ft. | Up to 37.8 cu. ft. | 39.3 cu. ft. gas / 36.3 hybrid |
| Maximum cargo | Up to 74.1 cu. ft. | 70.4 cu. ft. | 76.5 cu. ft. gas / 71.8 hybrid |
| EPA city/highway | Up to 29/36 mpg | Up to 47/40 mpg hybrid | Gas FWD 28/33; hybrid FWD up to 43/36 mpg |
Features and availability vary by model year, trim, drivetrain, package, and current inventory. Confirm the exact vehicle before purchase.
What should you check on a New Rochelle test drive?
For a useful Westchester comparison, drive each SUV over the same mix of local streets, I-95 traffic, and a tight parking stop. Bring the child seat, stroller, mobility device, or work gear you actually carry, and compare written offers with the same taxes and fees.
Customer questions and answers
Is the Rogue automatically the least expensive choice?
No. Model, trim, drivetrain, options, incentives, and dealer inventory all affect the final number. Compare written out-the-door prices on similarly equipped vehicles.
Should I compare fuel-economy estimates across different drivetrains?
Only with context. Gas, hybrid, front-wheel-drive, and all-wheel-drive versions can produce different EPA estimates and different purchase costs.
Which compact SUV is best in snow?
There is no universal winner. Appropriate tires, condition, speed, and driver decisions are fundamental; AWD can help acceleration but does not eliminate winter stopping limits.
Verify the details
We use Nissan, government, consumer-protection, and dealership sources. Vehicle facts come from the cited U.S. manufacturer information available on the review date. Our conclusions are original dealership analysis of those facts and the New Rochelle decision test shown above; we do not present an estimate as a hands-on measurement. Because model year, trim, drivetrain, and inventory vary, we identify what to match on the exact vehicles.
Source review date: 2026-09-08
- 2026.5 Nissan Rogue specifications
- 2026.5 Nissan Rogue brochure
- 2026 Honda CR-V specifications
- 2026 Toyota RAV4 specifications
- EPA fuel economy
- 2026 Toyota RAV4 brochure
Nissan of New Rochelle sells and services Nissan vehicles. Our goal is to help you choose the option that fits your needs, including telling you when a different model, payment method, or timing may be the better choice.
Related guides
Find more answers in our research center.
Nissan Answers, Ownership & News Center